Can You Really Make a Candle with Vegetable Shortening? The Ultimate Guide

The world of candle making is often associated with traditional waxes like paraffin, soy, or beeswax. But what if you’re looking for a budget-friendly, readily available alternative? Can you really create a functional, aesthetically pleasing candle using something as simple as vegetable shortening? The answer is a resounding yes, with a few caveats and considerations. Let’s delve into the fascinating world of shortening candles.

Table of Contents

The Allure of Alternative Candle Materials

Why venture beyond the established candle-making materials? Several compelling reasons drive the exploration of alternatives like vegetable shortening. Cost is a major factor. Vegetable shortening is generally significantly cheaper than traditional candle waxes, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious crafters or those looking to experiment without a significant financial investment.

Availability is another key advantage. You can find vegetable shortening in virtually any grocery store, ensuring easy access whenever inspiration strikes. This contrasts with specialized waxes, which may require trips to craft stores or online purchases.

Finally, there’s the appeal of resourcefulness and sustainability. Repurposing everyday items like vegetable shortening aligns with a growing interest in DIY projects and minimizing waste.

Understanding Vegetable Shortening as a Candle Medium

Vegetable shortening is a solid fat made from vegetable oils, typically soybean, cottonseed, or palm oil. Its primary characteristic is its high fat content, which is crucial for its potential as a candle fuel. Unlike water or other non-flammable substances, fats can sustain a flame when properly wicked.

However, it’s important to understand that vegetable shortening isn’t a perfect substitute for traditional waxes. It has a different consistency, melting point, and burning behavior. These differences necessitate specific techniques and precautions to achieve a satisfactory candle.

The Science Behind the Burn

A candle burns because the heat from the flame melts the wax (or in this case, the shortening) near the wick. This molten substance is then drawn up the wick through capillary action. The heat of the flame vaporizes the shortening, and it’s the vapor that actually burns, producing light and heat.

The effectiveness of vegetable shortening as a candle fuel depends on its ability to melt, vaporize, and sustain a consistent flame. Factors like the type of shortening, the wick size, and the ambient temperature can all influence the burning process.

The Pros and Cons of Shortening Candles

Before diving into the candle-making process, it’s essential to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of using vegetable shortening.

Advantages

Cost-Effective: As mentioned earlier, shortening is significantly cheaper than traditional waxes.
Readily Available: Easily accessible in most grocery stores.
Relatively Safe: When handled properly, shortening is generally safe to work with.
Odorless (Usually): Most vegetable shortenings are odorless, allowing for easy fragrance addition.
DIY Friendly: Simple process, requiring minimal specialized equipment.

Disadvantages

Soot Production: Shortening candles tend to produce more soot than paraffin or soy candles, especially if not wicked properly.
Melting Point: Lower melting point than some waxes, making them susceptible to melting in warm environments.
Weak Scent Throw: Shortening doesn’t hold scent as well as some waxes, resulting in a weaker fragrance.
Appearance: The appearance can be less aesthetically pleasing than candles made with traditional waxes.
Potential Rancidity: Over time, the shortening can become rancid, affecting the candle’s scent.

Step-by-Step Guide to Making a Shortening Candle

Now that you understand the potential and limitations of shortening candles, let’s explore the process of making one.

Materials You’ll Need

Vegetable Shortening (unflavored)
Wicks (choose the appropriate size for your container)
Container (glass jars, tins, or heat-safe containers)
Double Boiler or Microwave-Safe Bowl
Thermometer (optional but recommended)
Fragrance Oil or Essential Oil (optional)
Dye Chips or Liquid Candle Dye (optional)
Pencil or Skewer

Step 1: Preparing the Container and Wick

Begin by thoroughly cleaning and drying your chosen container. Center the wick at the bottom of the container. You can use a glue dot or a small piece of double-sided tape to secure it. Alternatively, use a wick sticker. Use a pencil or skewer laid across the top of the container to hold the wick upright and centered.

Step 2: Melting the Shortening

Melt the vegetable shortening using a double boiler or a microwave-safe bowl. If using a double boiler, fill the bottom pot with water and bring it to a simmer. Place the shortening in the top pot and heat until completely melted. If using a microwave, heat the shortening in short intervals (30 seconds) and stir until melted. Be careful not to overheat it. Ideally, the shortening should reach a temperature of around 180-200°F (82-93°C). A thermometer can help to maintain accurate readings.

Step 3: Adding Fragrance and Dye (Optional)

If you desire a scented candle, add fragrance oil or essential oil to the melted shortening. A general rule is to use around 6-10% fragrance oil by weight. Stir gently but thoroughly to ensure even distribution. If adding dye, add a small amount of dye chips or liquid candle dye to the melted shortening and stir until completely dissolved. Be careful not to add too much dye, as it can affect the candle’s burning performance.

Step 4: Pouring the Shortening

Carefully pour the melted shortening into the prepared container, leaving some space at the top. Avoid splashing or creating air bubbles.

Step 5: Cooling and Curing

Allow the candle to cool and harden completely. This may take several hours or even overnight. Avoid disturbing the candle during this process. Once the candle has hardened, trim the wick to about ¼ inch. This will help to ensure a clean and even burn. Ideally, let the candle cure for a few days before burning to allow the fragrance to fully bind with the shortening.

Tips and Tricks for Successful Shortening Candles

Making shortening candles can be a rewarding experience, but it requires attention to detail. Here are some tips and tricks to improve your results:

Choose the Right Wick: Selecting the correct wick size is crucial. A wick that is too small will produce a weak flame, while a wick that is too large will cause excessive smoking and soot. Experiment with different wick sizes to find the optimal size for your container and shortening blend.

Control Soot Production: To minimize soot production, ensure that the wick is trimmed to ¼ inch before each burn. Avoid drafts and burn the candle in a well-ventilated area. Consider adding a small amount of beeswax to the shortening blend to improve the burning performance and reduce soot.

Enhance Scent Throw: Shortening doesn’t hold scent as well as some waxes. To improve the scent throw, use a high-quality fragrance oil or essential oil. Experiment with different fragrance concentrations. Consider using a blend of fragrance oils to create a more complex and long-lasting scent.

Address Melting Point Issues: Shortening has a lower melting point than some waxes. To prevent the candle from melting in warm environments, consider adding a small amount of stearic acid to the shortening blend. Stearic acid will help to raise the melting point and improve the candle’s structural integrity.

Avoid Rancidity: To prevent the shortening from becoming rancid, store the candles in a cool, dark place. Add a small amount of vitamin E oil to the shortening blend to act as an antioxidant and extend the shelf life.

Experiment with Additives: Get creative and experiment with different additives to enhance the appearance and performance of your shortening candles. Consider adding dried flowers, herbs, or spices to the melted shortening. Be sure to use additives that are safe and non-flammable.

Safety Precautions When Making and Burning Shortening Candles

Candle making involves working with heat and flammable materials, so safety should always be your top priority.

Never leave a burning candle unattended.
Keep candles away from flammable materials such as curtains, paper, and clothing.
Place candles on a stable, heat-resistant surface.
Keep candles out of reach of children and pets.
Never burn a candle for more than four hours at a time.
Extinguish candles properly by using a candle snuffer or gently blowing out the flame.
Avoid using water to extinguish a candle, as it can cause the hot wax to splatter.
Work in a well-ventilated area to avoid inhaling fumes.
Wear appropriate safety gear, such as gloves and eye protection.
Be careful when handling hot wax or shortening to avoid burns.

Beyond the Basics: Exploring Creative Shortening Candle Ideas

Once you’ve mastered the basic shortening candle-making process, you can explore various creative ideas to personalize your creations.

Layered Candles: Create visually appealing layered candles by pouring different colored or scented shortening into the container in stages. Allow each layer to cool slightly before adding the next.

Embedded Object Candles: Embed small, non-flammable objects such as seashells, crystals, or dried flowers into the shortening as it cools.

Container Variations: Experiment with different containers, such as teacups, vintage jars, or decorative tins, to create unique and eye-catching candles.

Holiday-Themed Candles: Create holiday-themed candles by using seasonal scents, colors, and decorations. For example, use pine or cinnamon scent for Christmas candles, or pumpkin spice for autumn candles.

Final Thoughts: The Viability of Vegetable Shortening Candles

While not a perfect substitute for traditional candle waxes, vegetable shortening can be used to create functional and affordable candles. With careful attention to detail, proper wicking, and safety precautions, you can enjoy the warm glow of a shortening candle. While it may require some experimentation to achieve optimal results, the cost savings and readily available nature of shortening make it a worthwhile option for budget-conscious crafters and those seeking a more sustainable approach to candle making. The key is to understand its limitations, adjust your techniques accordingly, and prioritize safety throughout the process. So, go ahead and give it a try! You might be surprised at what you can create with a simple can of vegetable shortening.

Can vegetable shortening actually burn like a candle?

Yes, vegetable shortening can be used to make a candle. It functions as a fuel source, similar to wax in traditional candles. A wick is necessary to draw the melted shortening upwards, allowing for sustained combustion. The flame produced is generally clean-burning and relatively odorless, making it a viable alternative for candle-making in a pinch or for those seeking a different kind of candle experience.

However, it’s important to acknowledge that the burning characteristics will differ slightly from wax candles. Vegetable shortening candles tend to burn slower and may require a slightly thicker or more porous wick for optimal performance. The longevity and brightness of the flame depend on the specific type of shortening used and the wick size.

What type of vegetable shortening works best for making a candle?

Solid vegetable shortening, like Crisco, is generally the preferred type for making candles. The solid consistency allows it to hold the wick upright and melt gradually as the flame consumes it. While liquid vegetable oil can technically be used, it requires a different setup involving a container with a small opening for the wick and careful monitoring to prevent spills.

Different brands of solid vegetable shortening will work similarly, although slight variations in composition may influence the burning time and flame size. Experimenting with different wicks and containers is recommended to find the optimal combination for your chosen shortening. Avoid using shortening that has been previously used for cooking, as food particles can cause unwanted odors and smoking.

What kind of wick should I use for a vegetable shortening candle?

A cotton wick, similar to those used in traditional wax candles, is generally suitable for a vegetable shortening candle. However, you may need to experiment with different wick sizes to find the best match for your chosen shortening and container. A thicker or more porous wick often works better, as it can draw up the melted shortening more effectively.

Pre-waxed wicks are also a good option, as the wax coating helps to prime the wick and get the candle burning smoothly. Avoid using wicks made from synthetic materials, as they may not burn as cleanly or efficiently with vegetable shortening. Secure the wick firmly in the center of the container before pouring in the melted shortening to ensure even burning.

How do I make a vegetable shortening candle step-by-step?

First, choose a heat-safe container for your candle. Securely attach a cotton wick to the bottom center of the container using a wick sticker or a dab of hot glue. Make sure the wick is standing upright. Then, melt the vegetable shortening. This can be done in a microwave-safe bowl in short intervals, stirring in between, or in a double boiler on the stovetop. Avoid overheating the shortening.

Once the shortening is melted, carefully pour it into the container around the wick, leaving some space at the top. Allow the shortening to cool and solidify completely before lighting the candle. This may take several hours, or even overnight. Trim the wick to about ¼ inch before lighting for optimal burning and to prevent smoking.

Are vegetable shortening candles safe to burn indoors?

Generally, vegetable shortening candles are considered safe to burn indoors, provided they are used responsibly and under supervision. They produce a relatively clean-burning flame and minimal soot compared to some other types of candles. However, it’s crucial to follow basic candle safety guidelines, such as keeping the candle away from flammable materials, children, and pets.

Never leave a burning candle unattended, and always ensure the candle is placed on a stable, heat-resistant surface. Proper ventilation is also important to prevent the buildup of any fumes or odors. If you notice excessive smoking or sputtering, extinguish the candle immediately and adjust the wick size or container if necessary.

Can I add fragrance or color to a vegetable shortening candle?

Yes, you can add fragrance oils or candle dyes to a vegetable shortening candle, but with some considerations. Use fragrance oils specifically designed for candle making, as they are formulated to withstand the heat of the flame. Add the fragrance oil to the melted shortening just before pouring it into the container, following the manufacturer’s recommended dosage.

Similarly, use candle dyes in small amounts to achieve the desired color. Avoid using food coloring, as it may not blend well with the shortening and can affect the burning performance. Experiment with different fragrances and colors to create unique and personalized vegetable shortening candles. Always monitor the candle closely after adding fragrances or dyes to ensure it burns safely and cleanly.

How long will a vegetable shortening candle burn?

The burn time of a vegetable shortening candle depends on several factors, including the size of the container, the type of shortening used, the wick size, and the ambient temperature. Generally, vegetable shortening candles tend to burn slower than traditional wax candles, offering a longer-lasting flame. A small container with a standard wick can burn for several hours, while larger containers can burn for days.

To maximize the burn time, ensure the wick is properly centered and trimmed regularly. Avoid drafts, as they can cause uneven burning and shorten the candle’s lifespan. Also, allowing the melted shortening to pool evenly across the surface of the candle during each burn will prevent tunneling and ensure a consistent burn throughout.